Pokie

I can't decide between teh band or the neck piece.

Band has +2 melee crits and +75 CA damage
NEck has +4 melee crits +4 ranged crits and +50 CA damage

I've calculated the 2 melee crits vs. the 25 CA damage difference as a wash meaning I would pick up 4 ranged crits.

The only thing I can see that would make the ring better would be picking up the +5 melee crit neck piece from Vaults? Is this why I see all assassins wearing the ring?

Is there a raid obtainable ring out there that would equal the +5 crits the Vault neck gives?

Thanks!

__________________

Eyoafa

Hi,

I took the ring, because I have the 5 crit Necklace from VOES and I try to max out Melee Crit. The only ring which comes in my mind from raids, is the "ring of dark intent" which gives 35 haste, but comes from Milyex in VP.
But I think there would be not so much different if you choose the Neck and take Reet Knight Ring or something equal.

I think Neck alone is better than the ring, but the 5 crit Necklace + the Thuuga ring is really nice.

Eyo

Thaydrian

Agreed, I messed up and took the neck piece only to see a guildie get that +5 to crit item out of that anstance. I wish I would have know this before hand I would have taken the ring hands down.

__________________

TheUndertow

Took the ring b/c i had the neck piece.

__________________
ABing it - Jaack (80 Assassin) / Turmoil (80 SK) / Undertow (73 Fury)
think for yourself...Question Authority...think for yourself yourself

Fungie

thuuga neck + nax ring + reet eye ring = 8 melee crit, +3 slashing, +70 CA dmg
VoES neck + thuuga ring + reet eye ring = 9 melee crit, +5 slashing, +95 CA dmg

Only real issue is whether you have better rings than the thuuga ring, but that ring is pretty difficult to beat because +CA dmg is pretty nice. If you figure you do a CA about once every 1.5 seconds, then 20 CA dmg is ~ 1 melee crit if you're doing 3k.

__________________
Bill Clinton covers up murders & CIA drug-smuggling

Gonzo

Went with the Thuuga neck even with having Ganak's beforehand. The Thuuga neck ownz Ganak's Torgue and there are so many useful rings that I didn't want to add another for the sake of +1 melee crit and +25 CA damage. I plan on running Ring of Dark Intent and Ring of Four Winds for ring slots, so the +4 melee (or ranged) crit and +50 CA damage beats Ganak's +5 melee crit. My humble opinion of course.

Daimyo

I'm on a pvp server and have the shifting band ring and combined that with the thuuga ring and will grab the neck.

Please also do not under-estimate the MC ring. The +str and +dps is actually quite nice and is generally always up. I want to have 10 rings tbh, one for each finger/thumb.

~Daimyo

__________________
The daimyo (大名, daimyō) were the most powerful feudal rulers from the 10th century to the 19th century in Japan. From the shugo of the muromachi period through the sengoku to the daimyo of the Edo period, the rank had a long and varied history. It was usually, though not exclusively, from these warlords that a shogun arose.

Ardain

__________________
Claws of Veeshan - Innovation

Semi-good idea: Transferring from laggy shit German server to play without lag on US server.
Bad idea: Pay another 50 Euro to transfer back to another shitty German lag server.

Quote:

GZ SOE - you looted 100 Euro of the retarded corpse of Craithx....

Skratt

I took the neck cause fook i now have 32% ranged crit lol ...