Okay redid a bunch of stuff yesterday. looks like this. Please note I only have 133 AA points. I have been bounced between my zerker and my ranger due to guild needs so neither is maxed
Str 4483
Sta 44881
Int 44681
Bulking to berserk
Perseverence to Unyielding will
Shadows tree
Health and power 5
Fighter enhance rescue 5 battle hardening 5 Sneering assault 1
Warrior Saving grace 2 Rallying cry 5
Now with that we went into the Crucible last night. Group was Zerker, Warlock, Fury, Dirge, Ranger, Conjie. I only had aggro messes twice. Once when the warlock crited on a spell he had maxed through his AA trees (he did over 5000 or somemess BEFORE the crit hit and it was an AOE so I lost one of the three I had on me) and once to the swashie because he has a habit of not assisting through the tank.
This run only laster to the three named casters on the 2nd floor. We either needed a second healer, a mezzer or were missing something about the glowing platforms in the room for that fight (we were the first group in the guild in there so we are still working it out).
What makes this all interesting is that this was in defensive stance. Since we only had one healer being played by someone who doesn't use the toon (hubby was playing the wife's character for most of the fight). Did I occassionally have to pop a taunt or too to get adds back on me because of this? Yeah, but they never strayed long enough to do any serious damage, and thats what makes insolence rock anyway

. So for some instances at least (and Cruicible is the hardest of the Miragul instances) defensive stance is now a viable option it looks like.