Ryuujin

The DPS from BCG destroys the DPS gain from the Silten Sand Sash pre-VP, and still wins out in VP, even with the extra resists. 1 proc from BCG in a 30s fight is about right, and is more DPS than 2% crit will get you. The +damage on the sash isn't even worth considering, since it's so easy to cap anyway.

__________________

Terra

If you have doubts about bcg and are using praetor's guard, just imagine it's about the same dps without the crits.

__________________

Starpower

I have parsed with my bcg and then took it off and parsed with silten sand sash and I did more dps than with the bcg. For me the bcg is just resisted too much. The last time I parsed in CoD it was actually beat out by fireshield so I don't even bother with the bcg anymore. I have never bothered with it since.