Originally Posted by Kaylee

Miri also. I don't thnk Sazz was better then Ethar though.

And Eetums sucked ass so bad he had to roll a guardian. Sure he MT'd for TLW, but guess what, TLW never killed anything of note until he switched to guardian. I never really played with Oggi much, but he quit playing Oggi like what? 2 years ago?

Originally Posted by gungo

Ok then here is my final ALL TIME best list. IF there is any debate abotu a position please feel free to debate it =).
__________________________________________________ _________
Assassin: kiel (just parses high although xeqtr is about the same, neither have agro issues either)

Berserker: Yepe, (only zerk i have seen maintank all content for an extended period of time for a guild on this server)

Brigand: Sunlar (no clue take kaylee's word)

Bruiser: Deadnaut (just for owning in duels)(I may have been around forever and tanked some epics, but i have never been the top geared bruiser on server. I may start focusing more on gear/owning some parses soon. Goal is 2.5k+ zonewide in EoF)

Coercer: Apochs- (biased for lack of comparison, but completely geared and never seen him make an error)

Conjuror: Bubazeus (no clue who this is so take kaylee's word)

Defiler: Sinisterex (consistently the highest heal parser in every guild he was in)

Dirge: Beedub (There are to few competent dirges that play for any extended period of time)

Fury: Saphira (Saph is a beast on the parses)

Guardian: Sazzabi, (from anyone who has played with him, even people who played with ethar and current tanks all said this guy was amazing although he didnt use VOIP, wtf)

Illusionist: Twisting (3k parses, nuff said)

Inquisitor: Athilia, (only inqusitor i had solo healing/curing an offtank group and never having to worry about it. )

Monk: Brice (one of the most respected monks world wide, He tanked all epics before brawlers were considered tanks)

Mystic: Johnathan (fastest curer in the game and topped heal parses to boot)

Necromancer: Bizerk- (Seriously no contest)

Paladin: Raistin and Mournblade or lastat (no clue raistin tanks everything and mournblade has been around just as long doing the same, lastat is a sollid offtank no matter what gear he has had)- edge raistin for gearage.

Ranger: Ronlaen, one of the best rangers WW

Shadowknight: Eetum (and Oggiboggi) the last shadowknights to ever be main tanks for guilds. Eetums gets the edge due to kicking ass in duels. Although eetums was a douche

Swashbuckler: Ellistrae (was this the aod swashy that went to paradigm and basically owned world wide parses, because if so yeah)

Templar: Svanna, (kaylee sings the praises of svanna like its the second coming of christ)

Troubador: Stealthy (to many sucky troubs out there)

Warden: Phane and Iris, Hard to pick between these two, When iris played Iris full time, woud be tough to top. But Phane has the edge now with Iris's limited play time.

Warlock: Saltaf, just going by pure DPS numbers on the avatars Ive parsed of them.

Wizard: Xplosion, very beastly, puts up the numbers without constantly pulling agro.