Henladar Bloodheart

If it cant really be tested why even rank it? And if you cant tell then you cant have a logical criteria. GG try again venekor

Venekor

You can rank it, based on criterion. But the judgment is not the same as the criterion.

Xelus

I'm not saying it's impossible to test, there's just so many variables that must be accounted for. Simply saying so and so guild is the best because of the most WW firsts holds significant bias, you have to control for whether or not they beta tested, their server itself, things like that.

And no tests in the world can test to 100% accuracy, people try to control variables to reduce the amount of bias to get as close to 100% as humanly possible.


So if you want to spend a few years calculating who's the best, by all means go for it =p.

__________________

Henladar Bloodheart

The judgement is how you judged it.. AKA how you ranked it... the criteria is your thought behind your ranking.

The question was "Top guilds in EQ2" And i used Raiding Accomplisments to rank it which is criteria.

How about we both grow up.. get over this and admit we were BOTH wrong to a degree of some sort? cause this is really getting old.

Venekor

ROFL I WASNT WRONG!!@! You are now admitting you are wrong though!!!

YOu said it yourself there, you just admitted it.

The judgement is the list aka the RANKING.

The criteria is the WHY behind the ranking.

Just say venekor, "you were right, thank you for educating me what criteria means" and I will be done with it.

Henladar Bloodheart

You said ranking top guilds in the world based on raiding isnt on criteria... it is.. you were wrong to say it wasnt... AKA you were wrong.. that and that post started all this.

Venekor

No, I didnt henlander, I said that you saying a guild is "better" isnt criteria.

Henladar Bloodheart

I said my list was guilds being better at raiding.. you said it wasnt criteria.. you were wrong.. should i quote it?

Venekor

Hen, I know what I said, clearly you don't

You repeated said things like "a guild doing better then another guidl in a worldwide point of view overall. ".

Not to mention the fact that the thread got distorted to mean what makes one raiding guild better than another raiding guild.

But as for the main crux of the argument which was that you don't know the meaning of the word criteria, you were wrong and I was right.

Henladar Bloodheart

I had a criteria.. you said i didnt. You were wrong. Good game try again. Quite backpeddiling man you were wrong.