Go Back   EQ2Flames Forum > Everything Else > Everything Else of Everything Else

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 08-26-2008, 01:00 PM  
L337 Poster
 
Krontak's Avatar
 
Character: Krontak
Guild: Guildless
Server: Waiting for another game that isn't so damn laggy

Posts: 1,117
Photos: (0)

Default Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

So, Newsweek published an article after interviewing Petaeus regarding Iraq. One particular section of it caught my eye. This was regarding how the success came about. Here, I'll copy/paste the important part.

"Petraeus is careful not to credit all the progress to the surge of U.S. troops in 2007. The sea change came last year from a series of movements now known as the Awakening, when Sunnis, organizing around traditional tribal leaders, decided to turn on Al Qaeda as "an organization that embraces an extremist ideology, employs indiscriminate violence, and practices oppressive social customs," in the general's words. One of those customs was a ban on smoking. "That was the turning point when they cut the fingers off the first person who was smoking," he jokes. "Can you imagine an Anbar sheik being told he can't smoke?" So would the Sunni Awakening have succeeded without the surge? Possibly, he concedes, but the surge came at that time and helped empower Sunni leaders, paying their fighters and backing them up on the streets."

Avoiding the V Word | Print Article | Newsweek.com

Bottom line is this.

McCain continuously is blasting Obama for rather wanting to loose a war, than win an election. This has been one of his big talking points as of late. Obama fighting back claiming McCain is attacking his patriotism and McCain claiming he isn't attacking his patriotism, he's attacking his judgement.

After Petraeus' response, I find it hard to believe Obama showed poor judgment when the military commander in Iraq claims the insurgents could have been removed without the extra forces.

So, when McCain states the following:

"Not content to merely predict failure in Iraq, my opponent tried to legislate failure."

He is twisting the truth to benefit his chances to get into the White House.

Here's how I look at McCain's position on Iraq.

All the initial reasons we were given for justification to go into Iraq initially were proven wrong, the WMD's and the training of Al-Qaeda operatives was falsified information. Don't get me wrong, I'm glad violence has died down and the soldiers are somewhat out of harms way.

U.S. Casualties in Iraq

But, McCain is trying to draw attention away from the utter mistake Iraq was and the sacrifices made for this tragic mistake. McCain's focusing on the surge makes me think of a story.

One day, a man was driving down the road, he drove right through a red light and slammed into a minivan. As he approached the van, to his horror, he found a family inside, many of them unconscious or dead. He was able to drag one of the small children out of the car before it became engulfed in flames. The ambulance arrived and the medics were able to resuscitate he small child. Glad the man was able to save this small child, he drove home satisfied and went on his way.
Krontak is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-26-2008, 02:44 PM  
Regular
 
Character: Drychnath
Guild: unguilded
Server: Kithicor

Posts: 591
Photos: (1)

Default Re: Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

"Possibly" isn't "I think so, yes"

and he said, in the quote you show, that the surge came at the right time

so are you supporting the surge now, krontak? no, you're just trying to twist things so that people won't actually read the quote and think about it. did you link the story hoping we'd see the orange and say "ah, he's read it, i don't need to... he's RIGHT, good for him"

sorry, no, we'll go ahead and read the piece. The surge was effective. It's great that the Iraqi's participated too, in fact, it's absolutely necessary if we're ever going to be able to leave those people in safety. Acceptance of radical culture has to change, and American efforts are one of the agents of that change.
__________________
EQ2: Avenger Drychnath Malcherion -AB

Everything is on a great scale upon this continent, the rivers are immense, the climate violent in heat and cold, the prospects magnificent, the thunder and lightning tremendous, the disorders incident to the country make every constitution tremble. Our own blunders here, our misconduct, our losses, our disgraces, our ruin Are On a Great Scale.
-Lord Carlisle
drychnath is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-26-2008, 02:49 PM  
Regular
 
Character: Drychnath
Guild: unguilded
Server: Kithicor

Posts: 591
Photos: (1)

Default Re: Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

And your story? "Oops, I killed this whole family, but I saved one little girl, and then I left her an orphan with no means to support herself, so everything is OK now..."

Wow, what an idiot
__________________
EQ2: Avenger Drychnath Malcherion -AB

Everything is on a great scale upon this continent, the rivers are immense, the climate violent in heat and cold, the prospects magnificent, the thunder and lightning tremendous, the disorders incident to the country make every constitution tremble. Our own blunders here, our misconduct, our losses, our disgraces, our ruin Are On a Great Scale.
-Lord Carlisle
drychnath is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-26-2008, 02:55 PM  
Enhance your calm
 
Rinion's Avatar
 
Character: Rinion
Server: Zul'jin

Posts: 3,522
Photos: (38)

Send a message via AIM to Rinion
Default Re: Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

Quote:
Originally Posted by drychnath View Post
Acceptance of radical culture has to change, and American efforts are one of the agents of that change.
Why be so general? You can't really have a problem with Radical Buddhism could you? After all sir! Radical Buddhist don't preach Death to infidels.


I guess all I am really saying is "fuck politically correct"
__________________
"Before one can identify anything as "gray", one has to know what is black and what is white. In the field of morality, this means that one must first identify what is good and what is evil. And when a man has ascertained that one alternative is good and the other evil, he has no justification for choosing a mixture. " Ayn Rand
Rinion is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-26-2008, 02:58 PM  
L337 Poster
 
Character: Deson
Guild: Unbound
Server: Lucan

Posts: 1,471
Photos: (0)

Default Re: Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rinion View Post
Why be so general? You can't really have a problem with Radical Buddhism could you? After all sir! Radical Buddhist don't preach Death to infidels.


I guess all I am really saying is "fuck politically correct"
Actually they used to but that wasn't your point...

I hate PC but if it saves some lives and prevents major political misunderstandings I'm willing to tolerate it.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by LFG View Post
I used my best efforts to try and be supportive of SOE and did everything in my power to try and keep things professional and courteous between SOE and it's players... I will not stand back and be blamed for the incompetence of SOE management.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Locke View Post
I need to stop visiting this site, but I need my seasonal dose of spectating trainwrecks.

Last edited by Deson; 08-26-2008 at 02:59 PM.
Deson is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-26-2008, 02:59 PM  
L337 Poster
 
Krontak's Avatar
 
Character: Krontak
Guild: Guildless
Server: Waiting for another game that isn't so damn laggy

Posts: 1,117
Photos: (0)

Default Re: Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

You know what's interesting about the Anbar awakening. The current Iraqi administration is arresting the people we are currently paying to keep the terrorists off the streets for their previous crimes against the Shia.

Just wait until Saudi Arabia gets pissed at the Shia for attacking the Sunni.

And, I think you missed the point of the story, but I wouldn't expect anything less of you.

Wow, what an idiot.
Krontak is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-26-2008, 02:59 PM  
Enhance your calm
 
Rinion's Avatar
 
Character: Rinion
Server: Zul'jin

Posts: 3,522
Photos: (38)

Send a message via AIM to Rinion
Default Re: Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Deson View Post
Actually they used to but that wasn't your point...

I hate PC but if it saves some lives and prevent major political misunderstandings I'm willing to tolerate it.
did they really!? I need to research this!

Thanks =o
__________________
"Before one can identify anything as "gray", one has to know what is black and what is white. In the field of morality, this means that one must first identify what is good and what is evil. And when a man has ascertained that one alternative is good and the other evil, he has no justification for choosing a mixture. " Ayn Rand
Rinion is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-26-2008, 03:03 PM  
L337 Poster
 
Character: Deson
Guild: Unbound
Server: Lucan

Posts: 1,471
Photos: (0)

Default Re: Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rinion View Post
did they really!? I need to research this!

Thanks =o
Yes they did but it was long after the core religion had been corrupted into its myriad forms. Most of the radicals you'll find out about are warrior monks form Japan and fanatics in China but it's been awhile since I read any of it. Post what you find!
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by LFG View Post
I used my best efforts to try and be supportive of SOE and did everything in my power to try and keep things professional and courteous between SOE and it's players... I will not stand back and be blamed for the incompetence of SOE management.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Locke View Post
I need to stop visiting this site, but I need my seasonal dose of spectating trainwrecks.
Deson is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-26-2008, 03:26 PM  
God Damn, The Pusherman
 
Otis's Avatar
 
Character: Otis
Guild: Retired
Server: Blackburrow

Posts: 4,285
Photos: (0)

Send a message via AIM to Otis
Default Re: Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

lol - Drychnath is the Krontak of the right.
__________________
Otis is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-26-2008, 03:36 PM  
Regular
 
Character: Drychnath
Guild: unguilded
Server: Kithicor

Posts: 591
Photos: (1)

Default Re: Iraq victory without the Surge? Petraeus thinks so...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Krontak View Post
You know what's interesting about the Anbar awakening. The current Iraqi administration is arresting the people we are currently paying to keep the terrorists off the streets for their previous crimes against the Shia.

Just wait until Saudi Arabia gets pissed at the Shia for attacking the Sunni.

And, I think you missed the point of the story, but I wouldn't expect anything less of you.

Wow, what an idiot.
I didn't miss the point of the story, but at the same time I saw the problems caused. Compare it to Iraq. We go in, smite all of the parents (Bathists and Saddam) and then walk away. What happens to the little girl (the entire rest of the country now leaderless and torn to shit by bombs, looters, radicals etc)? Do they get to just go on with their lives? Or does some really bad shit happen to them? More than likely, the girl ends up on a psychologists couch for a few years, passed from foster home to foster home, gets raped by a couple of her foster dads and ends up a drug addicted hooker. But at least the guy that killed her entire freaking family in a firey inferno was able to save her life and drive off into the distance, self satisifed that he did a little good today!

We weren't going to leave iraq to be raped and murdered by a thousand little tribal chieftains all clawing their way to the top of the heap, some of their regions annexed by other countries and the rest torn apart in years of war and grief. Not like you liberals wanted, anyways. Your side calls the money spent every month to help Iraq get on it's feet, and protect it's people from radicals "war funds" I call it "humanitarian aid".

It was our responsibility to see that the little girl did more than just "live".
__________________
EQ2: Avenger Drychnath Malcherion -AB

Everything is on a great scale upon this continent, the rivers are immense, the climate violent in heat and cold, the prospects magnificent, the thunder and lightning tremendous, the disorders incident to the country make every constitution tremble. Our own blunders here, our misconduct, our losses, our disgraces, our ruin Are On a Great Scale.
-Lord Carlisle
drychnath is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are On


Sponsor Ads


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:58 AM.


Design By: Miner Skinz.com Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.1.0