LFG

I think the only thing that could get close to topping this thread is a "So who's your favorite NGD poster" thread. I think it's wonderful when we get others in the EQ2 community to join our fun here.

__________________

Serathe

She said she didn't raid in eq2. What the hell does adventure level 70 have to do with anything as far as making a difference on her opinion?

Sutex

Whoa, big guy. Dont get yourself so worked up over something like this, its not even about you. Sheesh.

LFG

It makes a massive difference in the context of this thread. Allow me to spell that out for you.

She is a level 63 who has never raided and is commenting on the quality of a series of articles about raiding in EQ2. She said she liked Tamat's "Born to Raid" series - which reinforces my view that the series was neither by raiders, nor for raiders. It was by a noob, for noobs.

The comment was not a negative one against Calthine at all, but it did prove my point nicely. If I need to spell it out for you further though, I will: she wouldn't have said that if she was more familiar with raiding in EQ2.

Thanks for your reply, and allowing me to wrap all this up with such a nice little bow.

__________________

Serathe

If your level 70 and don't raid its still the same is my thought.

LFG

If you're level 70 and don't raid, in my view, you have absolutely no business giving opinions about raiding, and especially about which world wide raid guilds are better than others.

That was my point in this matter from the beginning.

__________________

RadarX

Gaige voted for me! Other than that...*grumble* Tamat got all the good people hating him. I got a couple good ones but still....so not fair.

Lovelace

I voted for Tamat cuz I had never heard of him, and I've got respect for you, Radar. Didn't know it was gonna turn into a contest or I'd have voted for you instead *shrug*

Ladred

I voted for Tamat, because RadarX plays the best anti-hero evah!

Panthera

So I have to ask: Who are the "good" people?

__________________