Clear Cutter Machete goes to a dirge - Page 7

Kall · 08-21-2007, 04:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MysidiaDrakkenbane

IMO - it should go to the guildie who would benefit most from it. As all of you are working together as a team to accomplish similar goals, why give it to someone who wouldn't get the same benefits from it as someone else who would?

Because having a solid bard with a high morale that wants to play their class and tries on every encounter brings far more DPS to the raid than any piece of loot going to the "right class" could.

MysidiaDrakkenbane · 08-21-2007, 04:19 PM

I don't know about you, but I attend raids because I enjoy raiding. Getting gear is icing on the cake for me and if I see a monk or a bruiser that can benefit from a piece of gear more than I could, I don't bid.

But shit, not everyone plays like I do and this thread was asking my opinion.

Darenlok · 08-21-2007, 04:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gilgame

god darenlok is a whiny bitch, if you got a problem with a loot call, take it to the officers, not the fucking general gameplay forums.

Damn Gil your all pro. Obviously I didn't even want the item and wanted to start a discussion based on an item going to a class that may benefit from it less in comparison to their effectiveness (raid history) put into the raid. That was it. At no point was I whining over anything I mean what would I even be whining about? The fact that I didn't win an item I didn't want?

Open debate produces good things. That is what I was after. Quit being such a fucking prick.

Twister · 08-21-2007, 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MysidiaDrakkenbane

IMO - it should go to the guildie who would benefit most from it. As all of you are working together as a team to accomplish similar goals, why give it to someone who wouldn't get the same benefits from it as someone else who would?

Yet another retarded statement, If everyone worked together as a team to kill the mob that drops it, then why would there be someone more deserving than another? And please explain why you think a Dirge would not benefit from more dps?

Sharpteath · 08-21-2007, 04:25 PM

I want a refund for the time I have lost reading this thread..

Krontak · 08-21-2007, 04:34 PM

Be happy you've even seen one. We've been going to the 3rd floor since the beginning of April and have yet to see a CCM. That's almost 5 full months. Random spawns ftl.

MysidiaDrakkenbane · 08-21-2007, 04:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Twister

Yet another retarded statement, If everyone worked together as a team to kill the mob that drops it, then why would there be someone more deserving than another? And please explain why you think a Dirge would not benefit from more dps?

You can't tell me that one class wouldn't be able to benefit better than the other. Hence the reason for this discussion thread. I'd be pissed off if I had seen a really great bow go to a warrior and not a ranger. But I get it, some people are just greedy bastards when it comes to loot and consideration goes right out the window when using your DKP for certain pieces.

Twister · 08-21-2007, 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MysidiaDrakkenbane

You can't tell me that one class wouldn't be able to benefit better than the other. Hence the reason for this discussion thread. I'd be pissed off if I had seen a really great bow go to a warrior and not a ranger. But I get it, some people are just greedy bastards when it comes to loot and consideration goes right out the window when using your DKP for certain pieces.

And you can't tell me a Dirge is not entitled to a DPS upgrade.

P.S. I would roll on the bow too.

MysidiaDrakkenbane · 08-21-2007, 04:55 PM

Never said he wasn't. I said it would benefit the other classes more.

Quote:

I would roll on the bow too.

One of the differences between you and I.

Twister · 08-21-2007, 05:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MysidiaDrakkenbane

Never said he wasn't. I said it would benefit the other classes more.

One of the differences between you and I.

And you sir are a fucking idiot, if the CCM was an upgrade for every scout on the raid, then the scout who would benefit the most from it would be the scout that won it. same goes for a bow, I'd be a fool not to roll on a good bow if was a signifigant upgrade. Rangers and assassins are not the only scouts with CA's that require a bow.