Mirror of Reflected Achievements - Page 4

Thundolfe · 01-09-2008, 05:49 PM

You haven't really earned the right for an answer, in my opinion, and besides, it wouldn't matter.

I too am disappointed the mirrors don't work as previously advertised.

Caswydian · 01-09-2008, 06:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thundolfe

You haven't really earned the right for an answer, in my opinion, and besides, it wouldn't matter.

Ah, more excuses. Looks like you don't have a real response. Whatever. I win again.

Arch0n · 01-09-2008, 06:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Caswydian

The update notes do not 'clearly' state that one can have multiple devices. The update notes state:

1. One device can store one profile. This is true.
2. These devices may be used from one's home. This is true.

The update notes are neither false nor do they state anything about multiple profiles or multiple devices within one person's house.

Actually...

"One profile per device" in the context of a single player would imply many devices = many profiles.

In the context of the server population, then you'd be correct. "You (people) get one stored profile per (character) device".

Except for the part that says "Within your own home", not homes. From the context of the bullet point, I understood exactly what everyone else disappointed here appears to have understood: you can make ten devices and store one profile on each of them.

Either way, Sony = fail, this relatively minor point could have been clarified at any of thousands of opportunities leading up to prod, and it wasn't. Further, the mechs allow people to waste rares making an extra (useless) mirror... certainly no reason for that.

Caswydian · 01-09-2008, 08:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arch0n

Actually...

"One profile per device" in the context of a single player would imply many devices = many profiles.

In the context of the server population, then you'd be correct. "You (people) get one stored profile per (character) device".

Except for the part that says "Within your own home", not homes. From the context of the bullet point, I understood exactly what everyone else disappointed here appears to have understood: you can make ten devices and store one profile on each of them.

Either way, Sony = fail, this relatively minor point could have been clarified at any of thousands of opportunities leading up to prod, and it wasn't. Further, the mechs allow people to waste rares making an extra (useless) mirror... certainly no reason for that.

Ah, now this is very true. The notes themselves, while not untrue, are also on the ambiguous side, so there is the possibility of people interpreting them incorrectly. I certainly won't deny that the notes could have been written more clearly.

Dystrax · 01-09-2008, 08:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Caswydian

Ah, now this is very true. The notes themselves, while not untrue, are also on the ambiguous side, so there is the possibility of people interpreting them incorrectly. I certainly won't deny that the notes could have been written more clearly.

if something is ambiguous there is no incorrect interpretation. all interpretations are equally plausible. thats why its ambiguous.

Arch0n · 01-10-2008, 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Caswydian

Ah, now this is very true. The notes themselves, while not untrue, are also on the ambiguous side, so there is the possibility of people interpreting them incorrectly. I certainly won't deny that the notes could have been written more clearly.

I actually think they were untrue. Example:

"In your home, you may have one profile per device."

!=

"In your home, you may have one profile, regardless of how many devices you place."

Dexxa · 01-10-2008, 12:38 PM

I think one is all that should be allowed anyway. If the point of having AA choices is to further distinguish your toon from others of the same class, that point would be defeated by allowing everyone to have unlimited profiles.

Rueny · 01-10-2008, 06:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arch0n

Actually...

"One profile per device" in the context of a single player would imply many devices = many profiles.

In context of more then one toon using the same house, this would be correct. Many people have more then one of their toons using he same house,. this states that you will need one for each toon.

LFG · 01-10-2008, 06:09 PM

I think people are getting caught up in semantics here.

I've read everything written in this matter and don't see any kind of promise that anyone will be allowed to use more than one mirror to switch out more than one achievement profile.

Just be glad we got what we did, I think the opportunity to get a mirror is pretty generous, since that was something that was never planned.

Don't look a gift horse in the mouth. OMG, I'm talking like my grandfather.

LFG · 01-10-2008, 06:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dystrax

if something is ambiguous there is no incorrect interpretation. all interpretations are equally plausible. thats why its ambiguous.

When all interpretations are ambiguous, the one that will be enforced is the one that (a) best reflects the parties' original intentions, or (b) is best in accord with public policy. The most plausible, valid, and legally acceptable interpretation is the one that will be construed, unless no feasible interpretation can be given effect, in which case the agreement giving rise to the controversy will be nullified.