VP Loot Upgrade: An EQ2Flames Exclusive Preview!(lol) - Page 16

Slamdar · 03-26-2008, 01:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Summona

Brawlers aren't a support class either. Yea, we pick up adds. We cant tank named's or anything don't put us off in that category. If you have a good guardian his DPS currently should just be a little lower then the monks. Monk tanking ability isn't a little below guardian tanking ability so GTFO.

Our mt has 5,300 mit and can get 83% avoidance. No one is shouting nurf guardians because they have to be that leet to kill mobs. But when brawlers ask for dps gear . HOLD UP EVERYONE FREAKOUT!

You can tank Hoshkar sir.

Couch · 03-26-2008, 02:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slamdar

Brawlers != a dps class. Comparing gear for an archetype who's ONLY role is to dps vs. gear for a hybrid dps/tank class is dumb.

Gear from fucking Druushk should NOT be superior to Trakanon loot. The gi is overpowered, plain and simple.

Just saying.

Open your fucking eyes and read the pulse of power again. It's can be used for everyone.

Also, by your logic, hood from PR should be nerfed to 120 hp only since it's for scout, they don't need hp and it's from T1. It's dumb to have same hp as tank gear from VP.

Aphao · 03-26-2008, 02:21 PM

No one cares when brawlers ask for dps gear. They better be dpsing, because most of the time there is nothing else they can do in the raids.

The problem comes when brawler only gear starts dropping a lot. Raids only have 1 brawler in them for a reason. But so see some of the best dps gear drop for a gimp class that needs its own group? Thats just stupid.

bobz69 · 03-26-2008, 02:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Summona

Brawlers aren't a support class either. Yea, we pick up adds. We cant tank named's or anything don't put us off in that category. If you have a good guardian his DPS currently should just be a little lower then the monks. Monk tanking ability isn't a little below guardian tanking ability so GTFO.

Our mt has 5,300 mit and can get 83% avoidance. No one is shouting nurf guardians because they have to be that leet to kill mobs. But when brawlers ask for dps gear . HOLD UP EVERYONE FREAKOUT!

Um, pretty sure we had a brawler tank t8 tranquility, tank vp trash, pick up and tank anythign from kluzen - phara dar, so if you are saying you cant tank because your a brawler, you shoudl edit that and change to not being able to tank because you, your healers, or your raid sucks, probably all 3, brawlers tank as well as any other class.

Couch · 03-26-2008, 02:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bobz69

brawlers tank as well as any other class.

Lol, brawler can tank as well as guardian or any plate tank when they have more mitigation and uncontested avoidance?

Dude, get a fucking clue before posting.

It's something like bard can deal as much damage as assassin. Ya, they are scouts and they can deal dps as much as any other scout.

Slamdar · 03-26-2008, 02:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Couch

Open your fucking eyes and read the pulse of power again. It's can be used for everyone.

Also, by your logic, hood from PR should be nerfed to 120 hp only since it's for scout, they don't need hp and it's from T1. It's dumb to have same hp as tank gear from VP.

Something about Elysium brawlers...

Couch · 03-26-2008, 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slamdar

Something about Elysium brawlers...

Nice dodge.

I am glad that you agree with me that treasureseeker's band and hood from PR are overpowered and need a nerf since you were against to upgrade comparative gear from VP, such as pulse of power and mining cap.

Traxor · 03-26-2008, 03:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bobz69

Um, pretty sure we had a brawler tank t8 tranquility, tank vp trash, pick up and tank anythign from kluzen - phara dar, so if you are saying you cant tank because your a brawler, you shoudl edit that and change to not being able to tank because you, your healers, or your raid sucks, probably all 3, brawlers tank as well as any other class.

I didn't say brawlers couldn't tank. I said they couldn't tank epic named encounters. And no I don't mean mobs that are so fucking weak our brigand can tank them. I can tank epic named encounters that are are equal or weaker then pawbuster, yes.... does that include a weak ass named from vp, or one of they many fucked up avatars. =) you answer

Slippery · 03-26-2008, 03:03 PM

Your Brawlers must suck ass, because like Wayn said our Monk has tanked everything in T8 from all the mobs in VP to Avatars. I'm not talking just picking up the Avatar for a short period either, I'm talking Main Tanking the Avatar, Silverwing, and Phara Dar. They are fully capable of tanking, if yours can't that is a problem with your guild.

Couch · 03-26-2008, 03:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slippery

Your Brawlers must suck ass, because like Wayn said our Monk has tanked everything in T8 from all the mobs in VP to Avatars. I'm not talking just picking up the Avatar for a short period either, I'm talking Main Tanking the Avatar. They are fully capable of tanking, if yours can't that is a problem with your guild.

It's not a problem of brawler can tank or can't tank. It's the problem of why let them tank when you have better tank such as guardian or other plate tanks in raids.

Plate tanks have more mitigation and uncontested avoidance than brawler. Not to say guardian has best survival skill, ToS in this game.

It's dumb to let brawler tank when you have another plate tanks in raid.