The level 12 illu is an Apprentice, not in Raid lead.
Basically, he helped forming the guild, and we do let -70s in the guild(though not in preferred) in order to let them learn about raiding, and maybe grow into good raiders when they reach the higher tiers.
Sanguine code about this is:
As long as you're under level 70 you will never go above the rank of apprentice, and you are encouraged to pick up every chance to join raids and learn what your role is in them. Once you have reached level 70 you can apply to join our Mercenaries(The rank above Apprentice, mercenaries are not our main raid force but used as backups if needed).
We added this feature because we realised the number of actual good raiders are slim, and most have already found great guilds in Strike, F U R Y, Transcendence and the such. So in order to find untapped potential we will "scout" for new talents this way
Now.. Is this a sad and hopeless plan in your opinions? I thought it had some merit, but I'm a little biased.