Disturbed

Wish this crap would stop. I was recruiting into Chaotic Legion as a Bruiser, since they quit the game not long ago im now in another guild who is clearing end-game, avatars etc.

We lack one thing and thats the RW buff, yes it may get you on the Bench a few nights if you have a monk in guild aswell, but thats why alot of us are hoping it will get balanced out soon.

__________________

Aonach

It's not crap it's true. Bruisers bring nothing to and end game raid guild, monks RW buff is way more needed than anything a bruiser can bring. Sure some guilds have bruisers but I bet they would prefer you betrayed.

Disturbed

It is crap, i just said i was recruited as a bruiser into Chaotic Legion when they already had a monk, nothing was any different, actually it was monk's peel wasn't nerfed so they had an even bigger lead on us. So stop talking shit because that alone proves you completly wrong, why would a guild that kills stuff generally in the top 5 more often top 3 (see ROK clearance list) recruit an underpowered pos bruiser when they have a monk?

It's because they are useful, as i said before we lack one thing that has a big inpact and thats the RW. So what you said and i quote "if you want to raid end game in a good guild roll a Monk" is bullshit.

__________________

Traxor

IIRC didnt CL have two brusiers... I was a good friend of lizardling. What was up with that.

__________________
In The Face!!!!

Blanka

We have a bruiser and a monk in our guild. Our bruiser seems a little bit better for tanking due to the 10% dmg reduction on his mythical and we are pretty even on parses.

__________________

Aonach

Guess it depends on the guild then. Bruisers don't need to tank in RoK, not even on the sisters if you have decent guards, so 10% dmg reduction means fuck all on raids.

However I will admit that getting a bruiser and a monk on a raid together makes a good duo for dps buffs but until they make the bruisers buff back to +dps instead of +ca then I can't see why any decent guild would have a bruiser over any scout class if they already had a monk. Would be interesting to see a vote from top raid guilds on whether they would take a monk over a bruiser, I know what the answer is in my experience.

This is old ground so I'm done repeating it now i'll let disturbed live in his little fairy land of useful raid bruisers.

Trumak

Efob joins as bruiser when they have normack (monk). Normack quits efob betrays lizardling joins as bruiser.

__________________

Disturbed

You didn't need to repeat yourself, you were wrong before you even posted and it seems like your gradually changing what your trying to say

you orignally said "If you want to raid in the end game with a good guild play a monk." which i have proven otherwise, now your comming out with "Would be interesting to see a vote from top raid guilds on whether they would take a monk over a bruiser" ofc they would take a monk over a bruiser if they were to only take one, they'd be retarded not to atm in time, but that wasn't what you were orignally saying.

Try to remember what you said or re-read your own post before tring to win an argument.

__________________

Aonach

Disturbed, I'm not trying to win an argument. I'm discussing the topic at hand and putting over my point of view having been both a mythical using bruiser and monk in a very good end game raiding guild.

I see you agree with my points though, so I don't know why the fuck you are replying to me, sort of arguing with yourself aren't you? Are you just bored? Did your mum take away all your toys again?

Blanka

Our raidwide is so overrated, when I sit our dps really doesn't change the way people make it out to be. And I'd take a good bruiser over a fucking retard scout any and at the end of the day someone playing their class effectively instead of like a retard is more valuable IMO then having an extra scout. Also its nice to have a bruiser on certain fights.

__________________