Originally Posted by Thundaarr

I have had a similar problem in my guild, but on the Tythus fight. We had our beserker tank it, and 3 healers were having a VERY hard time keeping him up. (warden, templar, defiler, dirge, coercer in MT group) Our zerker had 3 peices of TSO, the rest VP gear, etc. He can tank Xebnok without missing a beat, kultak, etc... yet Tythus wrecked his ass. Same group, same healers, the SK hardly took dmg it seemed, and was even able to tank a couple of the adds from the portal without too many problems when they got on him and we got backed up due to bad port/AE (2 groups healers went down)

I know that SK's have lifetaps, but I cannot see why there would be such a disparity.