Rinion

Submited for your aproval sir.

So the real Coah has stated that he was indeed only talked to, about the scale, AFTER it was TAKEN from him.

Also Loudness, a member of Aftermath, has stated that the scale has been common for them in his quote. 5 - 6 in one night? seems common to me.

I understand why it seems rarer to you and other guilds though LFG, after all EQ2 RNG sucks. As I said in a ranger Thread. I farmed Deathtoll for near 6 months straight never missing a raid and I never got a Bazkul, While I've heard of other guilds commonly getting them.

At one point Kalidon even had me believing they took it out of the game, and then told me he had heard it from GM-Gulible.

Also, No I have never been on a raid that has had to give loot to a MEMBER tohold onto, their has always been at least one or two other officers present capable of holding onto extra loot.

__________________
"Before one can identify anything as "gray", one has to know what is black and what is white. In the field of morality, this means that one must first identify what is good and what is evil. And when a man has ascertained that one alternative is good and the other evil, he has no justification for choosing a mixture. " Ayn Rand

Widem

the scale is like the equivalent of getting a relic drop through KoS in drop rate sometimes you get nothing sometimes u get a shitton...its the recipes that can be rare.

Otis

LORE items?

Rinion

Sounds Good. Gratz Aftermath and company on your uber flame thread about reli...err a Scale.

__________________
"Before one can identify anything as "gray", one has to know what is black and what is white. In the field of morality, this means that one must first identify what is good and what is evil. And when a man has ascertained that one alternative is good and the other evil, he has no justification for choosing a mixture. " Ayn Rand

Cochy

The scale is a big deal as I believe in guild we only have about 5-7 total after using the other pieces we have made from Wuoshi drops. The bow (Rigid Scale Bow) if you care enough to look it up is clearly the best bow in the game. And to top it off per recipie drop you can only make the item up to 5 times, so they are a little bit more of a big deal than relic ever was. The Scale was given to Coah because the officers all have scales and they just went down the list of who would be in line to get a bow. Once Coah left the guild obviously he wouldn't be getting a bow so it makes sense that they removed the scale from his possession.

However the Scale is not the real issue here if Coah took a scale it's not the end of the world. It's the fact that he petitioned the person who took the scale and got their account suspended.

__________________

Dogmae

The scale wasn't the real issue for us, and has been deleted by GM Kimbial, so neither party will get the scale back anyways. If you would have actually read the thread you would see that the main issue was that Coah/Leethal, petitioned Bink for taking the scale back from him and got him banned. The facts are already stated earlier in this thread, and it isn't as you seem to think a whine that we want the scale back (We'll always get more), but was more of a Fuck You to Coah, for being a little bitch. And also was showing how much of a moron he/leethal/whoever was for petitioning about something that showed he broke the EULA by giving out his password to Bink (and I'm sure they checked logs for how many different IPs had used his account after that).

For the post about passing the account on to a family member, that is against the EULA also, you can purchase an account for your child, but then you can never play it. You can have your own account but your child can never play it. There is no "tired of the game" rule to let your family inherit your toons. And Coah / Leethal are 100% not related.

__________________

Dogmae

Just another note, Coah left the guild by saying raiding was too much for him and he needed more time for RL. In this situation, which he freely gave his info to several people in the guild, of course we took the scale back.

If Coah said, "I'm Leaving because im a whiny EMO bitch, and think that sometime in the futre, you may give somebody else loot over me" then we would have just said, oh well. But since he pretended to leave on good terms, and wasnt planning on logging in much, taking the scale seemed fair.

__________________

LFG

Ok thanks, I've only ever seen the one scale though, hopefully we get more soon.

__________________

Laodaron

Well, this is better than the asshat keeping it. Its not the best, but not the worst outcome either.

Rinion

Thanks for clearing that up "the officers all had" "went down the list of who would be in line", "was Given to Coah"

So it WAS allocated to him. It had to of been because he was "next on the list". You could of easily given it to someone else to hold.
Then He leaves the guild, yall get pissed and took it back.

If thats not an Indian Trader I dont know what is. Just becasue it wasnt made into a bow yet does not mean shit.

Then we have this.
Nice, Hi guys the scale was never the issue.
The issue was bink got suspended for takeing the scale.

Wait but if the scale was never an issue why did Bink take it from Coah in the first place?

Thats Pretty Lame Aftermath.

__________________
"Before one can identify anything as "gray", one has to know what is black and what is white. In the field of morality, this means that one must first identify what is good and what is evil. And when a man has ascertained that one alternative is good and the other evil, he has no justification for choosing a mixture. " Ayn Rand