Progression Thread Beta Feedback

[Brodek]

Originally Posted by Johnathon

Just because it isn't broke doesn't mean its the best way..

Same thing as riding a 1980 chevette with no bumper.. it may get you to work , but you don't want your friends seeing you in it.

Try thinking about other layouts that may work..

I personally think the chart would look good, but the mob names should be laid out differently.



And instead of X's, try different colors...

I like the idea having different gif's for the places. maybe even a gold ribbon for the first guild to clear or kill a named (with a link back to a permanent screenshot)

Like a GOLD for 1st place, SLIVER for 2nd, and Green for anyone after that.

THE COLORS are NOT RIGHT.. but here is the general idea of what I think would make a table look cool

I like this format, I was about to say that why not just change the color of the FTK on the mobs (aka rev). There has to be a seperate list to show when an avatar gets owned.

This format is better IMO, the list is just to long to follow, this format is smaller and simpler, I would just say go back to the kills by zone, to make the table a bit bigger and doesnt affect those bleeding eyes, although I like it showing all the names, that way it's just easier for Virex to update it.

[Thaddeus]

Why not use both? I like Jonathan's pic format over the x's though, less to "decode" lol. Put the chart up for easy reference, then go with the list below it to include FTK's and dates for all. I would agree with highlighting the FTK's in such a manner that they stand out. Everyone is happy.

EDIT: For those who may not be informed, Domona is taking a break from EQ2 and has asked Virex to take over the progression thread. That is why he's asking for input.

Virex, I would suggest you request editing rights of the original thread. I think it's important to retain the history.

[arturos]

I finally figured out why eveyrone has their damn panties in a twist about this fucking progression thread... they dont have mouse wheels... thats it.. it has to be..
either that or they are browsing with a damn phone... if that is the case then i can understand the need for changing the kills page. Problem is with any graph like that it will get larger.. right now its all cute and cudley cause there are only three guilds that are actually in VP

Wait till the rest of the herd gets there.. then that pretty little fucking spreadsheet will be just one big wall of download with slanted fucking names...

USE A GOD DAMN SCROLL WHEEL for gods sake... it takes what?? three rolls?? i tried it.. one roll half way down still in T1 land.. second roll you got T2 T3 and VP last roll is all contested... jesus if people put this much fucking effort into raiding as we do spreadsheets we all would be through VP by now instead of just revelations.. y'all make my damn head hurt...

[Virex]

As I said in the original post, this is not the new thread (don't post kills here). All I was doing is throwing idea's out there looking for feedback.

The picture idea is sweet but I don't think I'm the man for that. I personally don't want to have to edit a pic and re-upload it everytime someone gets a kill. If someone else wants to step up to the plate on that idea, it's all you.

And I want to rethrow out there that the table could be used as a quick reference guide for those new to the server or just hitting 80 looking for a guild. The massive list could sit right below it for the people that feel like they need it to stay in their life.

[krixkrix]

btw he cant get edit rights for the original thread. i asked LFG for editing rights for HHs old thread, and he said nay, copy and paste.

[Domona]

Originally Posted by Virex

Any idea why I can't edit my original post anymore?

Need to start a new thread. Suggested title Unrest Progression V.5.

PM the link to the new thread to LFG, tell him you're taking over progression and please provide you editing rights to the new thread, make it sticky, and drop the old one.

He's pretty quick when you get him all the info he needs to get it done in one shot

p.s. You have the same instructions waiting for you in PM on the Dominion forums but figured you weren't checking those Make sure you check for them here, though. That's how you'll be getting some of your updates!

[Brodek]

So dominion planing on getting a new tank after Virex takes over the thread, the curse of the progression thread cant be stoped

[Lilii]

Warriors of Virtue is missing Imzok's Revenge

[Brodek]

Yeah this is BETA thread, you have to go to progression thread v4.0 and wait for domona to fix it, Virex already said this isnt the real progression thread yet

[Lilii]

It has been on that other thread for a while now, but thats fine