Pumpkinhead vs. Matron - Page 5

Stork/Atris · 02-22-2007, 01:56 AM

Well we 2 pulled the Matron today, and after killin both PHH and Matron, i'd probably say that PHH is harder, but Matron is more.... idk Matron is a shitstain of an encounter, it was borderline retarted before the tree stripped ya, but now its just utterly stupid, but it feels good to finally beat it haha.

PHH I like cos its original, the Pumpkins, the one thing that buggs me, is that when he says, Because I am Dead, I can take off my head, 3/4 the time nothing happens, then randomly hellfire will come fuck you up, *shrug* currently PHH is harder I think cos of the randomness of it all, but both encounters could use some work, i think both of the encounters though are moving in the right direction, unique.

Pinski · 02-22-2007, 10:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stork/Atris

PHH I like cos its original, the Pumpkins, the one thing that buggs me, is that when he says, Because I am Dead, I can take off my head, 3/4 the time nothing happens, then randomly hellfire will come fuck you up, *shrug* currently PHH is harder I think cos of the randomness of it all, but both encounters could use some work, i think both of the encounters though are moving in the right direction, unique.

It's not random if you figure out the script.

Stork/Atris · 02-22-2007, 02:59 PM

so him saying the take of my head thing 10 times and somtimes the 4th one is the ae sometimes none of them arent random? if so i am totally missing the encounter.

Silver · 02-24-2007, 12:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stork/Atris

so him saying the take of my head thing 10 times and somtimes the 4th one is the ae sometimes none of them arent random? if so i am totally missing the encounter.

you're totally missing the encounter

Snark · 02-24-2007, 03:24 PM

its still poor and ambiguous design

freyaldo · 02-25-2007, 03:03 PM

I think people killed matron too often, and phh not often enough, this may look like that phh is harder.

Matron teleport can randomly pick mt-healers, or MT itself.

phh has some random in it,but not enough to make it really much harder than matron imho, although they are close in difficulty.

Pinski · 02-25-2007, 03:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freyaldo

I think people killed matron too often, and phh not often enough, this may look like that phh is harder.

Matron teleport can randomly pick mt-healers, or MT itself.

phh has some random in it,but not enough to make it really much harder than matron imho, although they are close in difficulty.

Well, obviously people killed matron more often than PHH, considering it's been up and beaten for a longer period of time. Not to mention Matron took people 2-3 weeks at first to kill it. Whereas PHH took 1-3 days to be beaten.

kyros · 02-27-2007, 04:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snark

its still poor and ambiguous design

agreed.

Grevious · 02-27-2007, 05:40 PM

Our guild has killed PHH and are working on Matron. Got her below 50% last time at her which was our first real try at her as our guild is relatively new and had to work up gear and our raid force. So yes from a guild who didnt kill Matron before PHH is way easier im sure Matron will be to once we figure it out a bit better.

Grevious · 03-02-2007, 02:09 AM

Well downed both PHH and Matron tonight and we did PHH with a less then optimal force while Matron took alot better makeup as people logged in late today. So from doing them back to back Matron by far harder not even close really.